A recent article published on Psychology Today shows why the comparison with Clever Hans does not hold when applied to nonspeaking autistic spellers. The author argues that the data accumulated about how these people access letters and build sentences cannot be explained by subtle signals from the communication partner. [1]

In the classic story from 1907, psychologist Oskar Pfungst demonstrated that a horse seemed to do calculations only because it read the reactions of the person asking the question. When the questioner did not know the answer or the horse wore blinkers, the correctness rate dropped drastically. The analogy is often used to suggest that spellers are guided by the partner. [1]

The cited studies show a different pattern. In 2020, researchers used eye-tracking on nine letterboard users. They indicated letters at about one letter per second, with 94% accuracy, looking on average at 71% of the correct letters about half a second before indicating them. [1]

A 2024 study removed the partner: 31 nonspeaking autistic adolescents and adults typed on an iPad mounted on a stand, without anyone holding the device. They were faster when letters formed spoken sentences than in random order, kept pauses at the beginning of words and showed preference for frequent letter pairs. [1]

Another 2024 paper tested a virtual board in augmented reality headsets, without a physical partner, obtaining an average accuracy of 95.8% on dictated words. The authors emphasize that these results indicate planning and linguistic knowledge, not a simple stop signal. [1]

Tests with a physical barrier, a kind of modern blinkers, did not stop the spellers. Placed behind a panel about five meters high and three meters wide, participants continued to write fluently, and one wrote even 'Better with the barrier.' [1]

The content produced suggests authorship. The described examples include unexpected family wishes, conversations about the day with names unknown to the partner, or surprising requests such as a trip to Disney World adapted to sensory sensitivities. [1]

The author argues that comparative labeling with a horse fuels the outdated assumption that lack of speech equals lack of understanding and has concrete consequences on access to education and on taking into account the requests of nonspeaking people. [1]

Categories:
Society

Sources

  1. Psychology Today Why the Clever Hans Analogy Fails Nonspeaking Spellers