German psychologist Alexandra Zäuner explains seven possible reasons why some people struggle to give good gifts, framing gifting as a love language according to Gary Chapman’s theory. She notes that gifts can strengthen relationships but also fail badly. [1]

Zäuner says people who consistently choose poor gifts often lack perspective-taking and empathy, meaning they cannot imagine the recipient’s daily reality, desires or what would beautify their routine. [1]

She describes a ‘refrigerator problem’ in gifting, where some people miss obvious signals like ‘I really want to read that book’ or ‘I would love a spa afternoon’, because they lack antennas for others’ cues. [1]

Upbringing shapes gifting habits: if gifts were low-value or stressful in the family of origin, adults may avoid emotional gifts or deprioritize birthdays, for example copying parents who exchanged only practical items. [1]

Perfectionism can block gift choice. People with excessive demands search for an ideal gift that does not exist, then retreat to safe vouchers they feel uneasy about, which hinders meaningful giving. [1]

Attachment anxiety influences giving. A gift shows closeness, effort and listening; people fearing intimacy may struggle to give personal gifts and feel uncomfortable receiving significant ones. [1]

Some people resist conventional gifting occasions like birthdays, Christmas or Valentine’s Day, preferring to give only when they feel like it. Giving out of obligation tends to feel loveless and shows in the present. [1]

Projection is a common error: many give what they themselves would like, assuming their preferences are universal, despite differences in taste, experience and joy triggers. [1]

Zäuner compares gifting to a language. A mismatched gift does not necessarily mean indifference; the giver may simply not speak that language due to missing cues, upbringing or internal resistance. [1]

She suggests that when one language fails, couples and friends can find other ways to understand each other and learn to appreciate each other’s accents in communication. [1]

The interview, published by Brigitte on 18 November 2026, is authored by Susanne Schumann and frames bad gifting as communication rather than lack of love. [1]

Sources

  1. Brigitte Psychologin erklärt: Warum manche Menschen nicht gut schenken können