A new Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology diagnostic framework for obesity, tested on 844,108 adults in China, the United Kingdom, the United States and Spain and published in Nature by researchers linked to King's College London, proposes moving beyond BMI alone. The two-step approach first confirms excess adiposity by adding waist circumference and waist-to-height ratio to BMI, then separates clinical obesity—where excess fat impairs organ function—from preclinical obesity where excess fat raises risk but organ function and daily activities remain preserved. [1]
When the updated definition was compared with the classic BMI classification, BMI alone failed to identify obesity in up to 8.6 percent of participants and misclassified up to 3.1 percent as obese when they did not meet the 2025 criteria. Obesity was linked to higher mortality only when identified using waist circumference in addition to BMI, not with BMI alone, and the groups showed different death risks during follow-up. [1]
Relative to participants without obesity by the combined definition and without organ dysfunction, clinical obesity was associated with a 69 percent higher mortality risk, while preclinical obesity was associated with a 19 percent higher risk. Most people with preclinical obesity—about 77 to 91 percent depending on the cohort—did not progress to clinical obesity over ten years, supporting individualized risk assessment rather than assuming universal progression. [1]
Lead author Professor Francesco Rubino said preclinical obesity should not be automatically treated as active disease nor dismissed as benign. He argued that some people may need preventive treatment whose intensity should be matched to individual risk, noting the importance of personalized, proportionate care for the roughly one billion people affected and for health systems, especially as obesity treatments advance with lifestyle counseling, surgery and GLP-1 analogues. [1]
The study highlights longstanding criticisms of BMI: it does not account for muscle mass, fat distribution, or influences of ethnicity, race and sex on the relationship between body composition and health risk. Alternative measures such as waist-to-hip ratio and skinfold thickness are being considered, and the authors call for global adoption of the new framework to guide public health policy. [1]
- Entities:



