Spanish philosopher Fernando Savater, 79, has reignited public debate on ethics and history by asserting that no one can accuse others of actions that all castes, races, and families have committed with genuine enthusiasm. This reflection, originally appearing in his column titled 'Paleoabusos' for the publication The Objective The Objective, addresses the common human tendency to highlight the mistakes of others while overlooking or justifying one's own. [1]
Savater's arguments emerge within the context of geopolitical controversies regarding the 'black legend' and calls for Spain to issue an official apology to Mexico for the conquest of America. He argues that submission, violence, and conquest are not exclusive to any single nation or civilization, rejecting the notion that contemporary Spanish citizens should bear hereditary guilt from centuries ago. He notes that no people, including pre-Hispanic societies in Mexican territory, can claim a historical trajectory entirely free of abuses of power. [1]
Central to Savater's critique is the concept of 'presentism'—the tendency to judge past eras using the legal codes and ethical sensitivities of the 21st century. According to the writer, applying such selective filters to the past often serves immediate political gains or ideological interests rather than a genuine desire to understand historical complexity. He suggests that assigning a single culprit while granting retrospective innocence to others obscures the fact that human rights and moral progress are recent, fragile achievements rather than the starting point of any ancient society. [1]
The philosopher extends these historical observations to the intimate sphere of daily life, viewing them as a mirror for individual contradictions. [1]
Savater observes that humans frequently experience indignation when others claim shared credit, while conveniently forgetting the times they benefited from others' help without acknowledgment. He posits that applying a universal ethical rule is far more demanding than detecting faults in others, as it requires admitting one's own mistakes without immediately listing the flaws of others to balance the score. [1]
Acknowledging that imperfection and the drive for dominance are universal human traits is not intended to justify past atrocities or ignore current injustices. Instead, Savater invites people to move beyond victimhood and fictitious moral superiority to view history with maturity. He argues that if society accepts that no community is free of both light and shadow, the true ethical commitment shifts from searching for dead culprits to ensuring such abuses are not repeated in the present. [1]
Viewing history with maturity, therefore, involves accepting the inherent shadows of every society and defining true ethics as the active prevention of abuse today. [1]
Savater remains one of the most read and debated voices in contemporary Spanish thought due to his ability to link civilizational dilemmas with common sense. Through decades as a professor, columnist, and essayist, he has used irony and paradox to bring philosophy to a wider audience. His body of work, ranging from influential books like 'Ethics for Amador' and 'Politics for Amador' to his recent opinion pieces, advocates for an adult citizenry that is responsible for its current actions and free from imposed dogmas. [1]
- Categories:
- Culture
- Entities:



